The Best Beaches on Shelter Island
If you’re dreaming of an escape where the sun kisses the sand, the waves whisper tranquility, and privacy is the ultimate luxury, look no further than Shelter Island. Nestled away from the hustle and bustle of New York City, this hidden gem is home to some of the most exclusive and pristine beaches on the East Coast. With beaches spanning across 20 miles of coastline, we’re going to share the best beaches among this tucked-away paradise.
Wades Beach: A Secluded Paradise
Wades Beach is the epitome of Shelter Island’s charm. With its gentle waves and powdery sand, it’s the perfect spot for a leisurely day in the sun. Setting itself apart from other beaches is its sense of seclusion; it’s like having your own private oasis. The calm waters make it ideal for families or those seeking a peaceful escape from the everyday hustle. Comfort stations and lifeguards along the beach make it easy for families to enjoy a beach outing with peace of mind.
Menhadden Lane (Hay Beach)
Ranking high on the list for beaches with breathtaking panoramic views is Menhadden Lane (Hay Beach). With views of Gardiners Bay and the Bug Light Lighthouse, Hay Beach offers an exclusive atmosphere. Although there are no services at this beach, it is the perfect spot for a romantic outing or a walk with your four-legged friends.
Crescent Beach aka Sunset Beach
For those who believe a beach day should end with a breathtaking sunset, Crescent Beach, also known as Sunset Beach is the place to be. The soft golden sands and panoramic views make it the ultimate spot to watch the sun dip below the horizon. Crescent Beach offers lifeguards, comfort stations, and other services stretching over a half mile long; it is the island’s most popular beach with Pridwin Hotel, and the infamous Sunset Beach Hotel just steps away.
Shell Beach
Tucked away in quiet seclusion, Shell Beach beckons those with a love for discovery. Only accessible by water or via bike on the unpaved Oak Tree Lane, Shell Beach is plenty full of outdoor activities. Beachgoers often enjoy paddle boarding, kayaking, or swimming around the point and in the protected inlet of West Neck Harbor.
Each beach on the island seems like a well-kept secret, shared only among those lucky enough to discover this exclusive island. Whether you’re seeking family fun, a romantic getaway, or a solo retreat, Shelter Island’s beaches cater to your every desire, wrapped in an exclusive, welcoming embrace.
